Take This Waltz (2011)
Michele Williams has this undeniable gift of making us believe her. Truly believe her. Take her role in this film, for instance. It would be very difficult to believe that a woman who is very believably in love with her mega adorbs husband (Seth Rogen, hello!) can, literally out of the blue, develop a crush (and then some) on a rickshaw driver, named Daniel (Luke Kirby). Yet, in this case we believe and are fully sucked into Margot’s (that’s Michelle) struggle to make a choice. Tough stuff.